On Monday an IBF board meeting will discuss a show cause notice
issued to Sahara TV president Mahesh Prasad for speaking his mind
on conditional access in the task force (reported first by indiantelevision.com)
--- views that are not in tune with the broad IBF stand, as claimed.
The grounds of the show cause to Prasad are similar to the one when
earlier this week IBF president and Prasar Bharati CEO KS Sarma
disagreed with an foundation presentation to the parliamentary standing
committee on IT, telecom and convergence on one-city rollout of
Sarma is learnt to have asserted that an IBF sub-committee's view
on CAS, including a one-city rollout, cannot be regarded as the
view of all the members of the foundation, a lot of who are for
CAS in all the metros.
But an IBF source stated categorically that it is being made clear
that there would be no difference of opinion in the foundation on
issues that are vital for the industry like CAS.
Now, if Sarma quits as the president of the IBF and other members
like Sahara TV and SABe TV also oppose a one-city rollout of CAS
as a test case, as asserted by the IBF to the standing committee
members, a situation is likely to arise when the free to air channels,
led by Doordarshan, form a separate body.
As per information available, some talks in this regard have been
held informally amongst some interested parties, inclusing some
According to a representative of an FTA channel, the IBF seems
to have been "hijacked" by those managing pay channels, which feel
that their stakes in the game are bigger. A lack of adequate number
of set top boxes in the metros post-14 July may lead to chaos that
may effect the pay channels' viewership and advertising revenue.
The government has mandated that all pay channels will have to
be routed through a STB in a post CAS regime after July 14.
According to an IBF member today, "If there is a majority view
at the IBF board meet that Sahara's Prasad and foundation president
Sarma have views that are contrary to others and that there would
be difficulty with them around, then Sarma would have no option
but to go since the president holds an ex-officio post and is elected
by other members."
When indiantelevision.com attempted to cross-check facts with Sarma,
he refused to comment on the growing division within the IBF, saying,
"Other things are confidential, but if the board of the IBF feels
I have to go, then I will go."
Cable operators are not the only unhappy lot. The way things relating
to CAS have proceeded has also created a division amongst the broadcasters.
The FTA channels feel that those managing pay channels have hijacked
the task force on CAS and have been pushing their viewpoint, while
discarding the interest of others.
In the forefront of this FTA vs. pay channels battle is the Subrata
Roy-promoted Sahara TV whose president Mahesh Prasad has in the
past said that the likes of ESPN, Zee and even Star have been soft-pedaling
the real issues of the industry in a post CAS scenario. Prasad's
contention has been that the pay channels have an agenda of their
own and that agenda doesn't have place for free to air channels
like Sahara, SABe TV and Aaj Tak.
However, when indiantelevision tried to get an official response
from Prasad, he refused to say anything.
But if the likes of Sahara TV and Prasar Bharati have the guts
to stand up for their own right and split from the IBF to form an
association of the free to air channels, it would be nothing short
of a coup.
This polarisation may get accentuated as the CAS rollout deadline
draws near and the pay channels, cutting across bouquets and party
lines, try forming super bouquets for subscribers. Already, a promo,
created by Star featuring Tulsi from Ektaa kapoor's popular soap,
aimed at "educating" the consumer on CAS has started on
other channels too, like HBO.
Can the FTA channels stand up against the pay channels? Will Sarma
continue as the president of the IBF? Will Prasar Bharati continue
to be a member of the IBF if Sarma is forced to quit? These are
questions that can only get answered next week after the IBF board
has met. So, keep tuned in till then.
A word of caution: there may be an anti-climax too, for the media
if IBF manages to defuse the tension amongst members amicably.